Rent vs Buy in New York, NY
Monthly cost of renting vs owning a median-priced home · 30-yr fixed, 20% down
Renting looks favorable in New York, NY
Price-to-rent ratio is 23.2 (under 15 favors buying, over 21 favors renting). Renting costs $2,971/mo; owning runs about $6,310/mo — $3,339/mo more to own.
| Monthly cost to own | Amount |
|---|---|
| Mortgage (P&I, 7.28% rate) | $4,520 |
| Property tax | $757 |
| Home insurance | $344 |
| Maintenance | $688 |
| Total to own | $6,310 |
| Average 2BR rent | $2,971 |
Based on a median home value of $825,854 with a $165,171 down payment. Owning also builds equity over time, which a monthly comparison doesn't capture. Estimates use national averages for taxes, insurance and maintenance — your actual costs will vary.